While it may seem counterintuitive, it’s not at all uncommon for people to experience a downgrade in their digestive regularity alongside an upgrade in their diet quality. Here are three of the most common reasons why – and how to fix them.
1. Your new diet lacks soluble fiber.
Many popular diet regimens – like gluten-free, paleo and low-carb plans – significantly cut grains, and some involve a reduction in root vegetable and fruit intake as well. These foods, which are rich in a type of fiber called soluble fiber, are often replaced by lower-carb alternatives like leafy greens, berries and nuts, which are rich in a type of fiber called insoluble fiber.
While this may seem like an even trade, in fact, the two types of fiber behave very differently in your digestive tract. Soluble fiber can hold onto water, serving to plump up your poops and help keep them bulky and soft, no matter how long their journey to the exit may last. The insoluble fiber that predominates in “roughage,” veggie skins and seeds, on the other hand, can’t really hold onto water as it passes through the digestive tract. Therefore, if you’re someone whose bowels trend toward the slower side, there’s a fair chance that your insoluble fiber-predominant diet can produce poops prone to being hard and dried out by the time they reach the end of their digestive journey.
If this sounds like you, try to include more zucchini, carrots, winter squash, pumpkin, chia seeds, avocado, cantaloupe or all of the above into your diet. If that isn’t an option, then magnesium supplements in doses of 400 to 500 milligrams taken at night will help draw extra water into your bowel and speed your stool along to help promote softer, more expeditious evacuations; this is particularly helpful for people experiencing tiny, hard little balls of stool. If your stools are large but just too hard to pass comfortably, an over-the-counter stool softener like docusate sodium (Colace) may help them hold on to moisture better. Another potentially helpful option is a soluble fiber supplement, like Benefiber or Citrucel.
2. Your new diet is too low in fat.
When people make dietary changes like giving up dairy, switching from eggs to egg whites or adopting a more plant-based diet, it often results in a whole lot less fat. What you may not know, however, is that fat plays a role in stimulating motility – or forward motion – in the colon, which in turn promotes more regular bowel movements.
A nerve signal called the gastrocolic reflex is one way that our upstream digestive organs (the stomach and small intestine) communicate with the downstream digestive organs (namely, the colon) to let them know what is on its way so they can prepare. Very large meals and meals that contain a decent amount of fat both stimulate this communication reflex, essentially informing the colon that a significant amount of food has just entered the system. In response to the gastrocolic reflex, the colon ramps up its motility to make some room for what’s headed its way. (The gastrocolic reflex is one reason why very high-fat meals can cause an urgent need to poop soon after a meal, and even diarrhea in some people.)
3. Your new diet ditched natural sugars.
Some of the more restrictive diet regimens in circulation these days take a pretty hard-line approach to foods that have more than a minimal amount of naturally-occurring sugar, like milk or yogurt; sweeter fruits like bananas, grapes, mango or watermelon; dried fruit like raisins; and even certain veggies like carrots and beets.
However, many of the natural sugars contained in such foods – the lactose in dairy foods, the fructose in fruit, the sorbitol in dried fruits – can exert a mild laxative effect in our colons by attracting water into the bowel. So if you’d been eating foods on this list regularly, you may not have realized to what extent they were contributing to your previously smooth digestive function in the form of softer stools.
I don’t advocate for restricting any whole fruits, vegetables or unsweetened dairy products on the basis of their natural sugar content; I’ve never seen someone gain excess weight or develop Type 2 diabetes because they ate too many carrots or bananas. But if you prefer to avoid such foods, you might benefit from finding another way to attract some extra moisture into your plumbing. Magnesium in doses of 400 to 500 milligrams taken at night often does the trick in a natural way, as can very high doses of vitamin C (2,000 milligrams). Supplemental magnesium should not be taken by people with kidney problems, and people with a history of kidney stones should avoid such high doses of vitamin C.